9 Mar 2010 · 5:51 PM · Division 3
Fairer Private Health Insurance Incentives Bill 2009 [No. 2]
- Official title
- Fairer Private Health Insurance Incentives Bill 2009 [No. 2] - Second Reading - Read a second time
Tied vote
- Aye
- 33
- No
- 33
- Not recorded voting
- 10
“Not recorded voting” is everyone eligible who isn't recorded as Aye or No, for example absent, paired, or presiding.
What was decided
An equal number of senators voted in favour and against a motion that the bill be read for a second time,(Read more about the stages that a bill must pass through to become a law here. ) which was introduced by Senator Joe Ludwig. Because no majority was formed, the motion was negatived and so the bill will not be proceeding.
Background to the bill
This bill is part of a package of three bills, which include the Fairer Private Health Insurance Incentives (Medicare Levy Surcharge) Bill 2009 (No. 2) and the Fairer Private Health Insurance Incentives (Medicare Levy Surcharge—Fringe Benefits) Bill 2009 (No. 2). It was introduced to reduce the amount of private health insurance rebate eligible taxpayers with complying private health insurance are entitled to when their income for surcharge purposes is above the relevant Medicare levy surcharge threshold.(More information about the bill, including its explanatory memorandum, is available here.)
Summary written by They Vote For You contributors. Read it with the debate
Policies this vote counts towards
- Decreasing the private health insurance rebateSupporters vote Aye · counts strongly
Votes by party
Votes by party as a table
| Party | Aye | No |
|---|---|---|
| Australian Labor Party | 28 | 0 |
| Liberal Party | 0 | 27 |
| Australian Greens | 5 | 0 |
| National Party | 0 | 4 |
| Country Liberal Party | 0 | 1 |
| Deputy Senate President | 0 | 1 |
| Family First Party | 0 | 1 |
| Senate President | 1 | 0 |
How each member voted
Aye · 34
- Bob BrownTasmania · Greens
- Sarah Hanson-YoungSA · Greens
- Scott LudlamWA · Greens
- Christine MilneTasmania · Greens
- Rachel SiewertWA · Greens
- Mark ArbibNSW · Labor
- Catryna BilykTasmania · Labor
- Mark BishopWA · Labor
- Carol BrownTasmania · Labor
- Doug CameronNSW · Labor
- Kim CarrVictoria · Labor
- Jacinta CollinsVictoria · Labor
- Trish CrossinNT · Labor
- Chris EvansWA · Labor
- Don FarrellSA · Labor
- John FaulknerNSW · Labor
- David FeeneyVictoria · Labor
- Michael ForshawNSW · Labor
- Mark FurnerQueensland · Labor
- Annette HurleySA · Labor
- Steve HutchinsNSW · Labor
- Kate LundyACT · Labor
- Gavin MarshallVictoria · Labor
- Anne McEwenSA · Labor
- Jan McLucasQueensland · Labor
- Claire MooreQueensland · Labor
- Kerry O'BrienTasmania · Labor
- Helen PolleyTasmania · Labor
- Louise PrattWA · Labor
- Nick SherryTasmania · Labor
No · 34
- Nigel ScullionNT · CLP
- Stephen ParryTasmania · Deputy Senate President
- Steve FieldingVictoria · Family First
- Judith AdamsWA · Liberal
- Christopher BackWA · Liberal
- Guy BarnettTasmania · Liberal
- Cory BernardiSA · Liberal
- Simon BirminghamSA · Liberal
- Sue BoyceQueensland · Liberal
- George BrandisQueensland · Liberal
- David BushbyTasmania · Liberal
- Michaelia CashWA · Liberal
- Richard ColbeckTasmania · Liberal
- Helen CoonanNSW · Liberal
- Mathias CormannWA · Liberal
- Alan EgglestonWA · Liberal
- Alan FergusonSA · Liberal
- Concetta Fierravanti-WellsNSW · Liberal
- Mitch FifieldVictoria · Liberal
- Bill HeffernanNSW · Liberal
- Gary HumphriesACT · Liberal
- David JohnstonWA · Liberal
- Ian MacdonaldQueensland · Liberal
- Brett MasonQueensland · Liberal
- Nick MinchinSA · Liberal
- Marise PayneNSW · Liberal
- Michael RonaldsonVictoria · Liberal
- Scott RyanVictoria · Liberal
- Judith TroethVictoria · Liberal
- Russell TroodQueensland · Liberal
Spotted a mistake? Report a correction.