11 Oct 2016 · 6:20 PM · Division 3
National Cancer Screening Register Bill 2016 and another
- Official title
- National Cancer Screening Register Bill 2016 and another - Consideration in Detail - Penalties for data breach
Noes in the majority
This says only which side won the vote, because what Aye and No meant here depends on the exact question put in the chamber.
- Aye
- 69
- No
- 75
- Not recorded voting
- 6
“Not recorded voting” is everyone eligible who isn't recorded as Aye or No, for example absent, paired, or presiding.
What was decided
The majority voted against amendments introduced by Labor MP Catherine King, which means they were unsuccessful.
What were the amendments?
MP King explained her amendments by saying that:
We do not believe that the penalties in this bill or in the government's amendments go far enough.
...
When it comes to the penalties, particularly given that the government signed a contract with a for-profit provider four days before the election, they are miniscule in this bill—$21,000 for a breach of data for a for-profit organisation like Telstra is simply not good enough. So the amendments that we are moving say very clearly that there needs to be higher penalty units within the bill itself and they should not deferred by seeking reparation through the Privacy Act.
We actually think they need to be within this bill itself.
Find out more about the bill
The two bills under discussion are the:
- National Cancer Screening Register Bill 2016
- National Cancer Screening Register (Consequential and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2016
Together, they create a National Cancer Screening Register. Read more about them in the bills digest.
Motion text
See OpenAustralia for the motion text.
Summary written by They Vote For You contributors. Read it with the debate
Policies this vote counts towards
- Increasing penalties for breach of dataSupporters vote Aye · counts strongly
Votes by party
Votes by party as a table
| Party | Aye | No |
|---|---|---|
| Australian Labor Party | 65 | 0 |
| Liberal Party | 0 | 55 |
| National Party | 0 | 14 |
| Independent | 2 | 2 |
| Centre Alliance | 1 | 0 |
| Liberal National Party | 0 | 1 |
| Pauline Hanson's One Nation Party | 0 | 1 |
| Speaker | 1 | 0 |
How each member voted
Aye · 69
- Anthony AlbaneseGrayndler · Labor
- Anne AlyCowan · Labor
- Sharon BirdCunningham · Labor
- Chris BowenMcMahon · Labor
- Gai BrodtmannCanberra · Labor
- Tony BurkeWatson · Labor
- Linda BurneyBarton · Labor
- Mark ButlerHindmarsh · Labor
- Terri ButlerGriffith · Labor
- Anthony ByrneHolt · Labor
- Jim ChalmersRankin · Labor
- Nick ChampionWakefield · Labor
- Lisa ChestersBendigo · Labor
- Jason ClareBlaxland · Labor
- Sharon ClaydonNewcastle · Labor
- Julie CollinsFranklin · Labor
- Pat ConroyShortland · Labor
- Justine ElliotRichmond · Labor
- Kate EllisAdelaide · Labor
- David FeeneyVictoria · Labor
- Joel FitzgibbonHunter · Labor
- Mike FreelanderMacarthur · Labor
- Steve GeorganasAdelaide · Labor
- Andrew GilesScullin · Labor
- Luke GoslingSolomon · Labor
- Tim HammondPerth · Labor
- Ross HartBass · Labor
- Chris HayesWerriwa · Labor
- Julian HillBruce · Labor
- Emma HusarLindsay · Labor
No · 73
- Julia BanksChisholm · Independent
- Andrew GeeCalare · Independent
- Andrew WallaceFisher · LNP
- Tony AbbottWarringah · Liberal
- John AlexanderBennelong · Liberal
- Kevin AndrewsMenzies · Liberal
- Karen AndrewsMcPherson · Liberal
- Julie BishopCurtin · Liberal
- Russell BroadbentMonash · Liberal
- Scott BuchholzWright · Liberal
- Steven CioboMoncrieff · Liberal
- David ColemanBanks · Liberal
- Chris CrewtherDunkley · Liberal
- Peter DuttonDickson · Liberal
- Warren EntschLeichhardt · Liberal
- Trevor EvansBrisbane · Liberal
- Jason FalinskiMackellar · Liberal
- Paul FletcherBradfield · Liberal
- Nicolle FlintBoothby · Liberal
- Ian GoodenoughMoore · Liberal
- Andrew HastieCanning · Liberal
- Alex HawkeMitchell · Liberal
- Sarah HendersonVictoria · Liberal
- Luke HowarthPetrie · Liberal
- Greg HuntFlinders · Liberal
- Steve IronsSwan · Liberal
- Michael KeenanStirling · Liberal
- Craig KellyHughes · Liberal
- Andrew LamingBowman · Liberal
- Craig LaundyReid · Liberal
Spotted a mistake? Report a correction.