28 Feb 2013 · 11:30 AM · Division 1
Renewable Energy (Electricity) Amendment (Excessive Noise from Wind Farms) Bill 2012
- Official title
- Renewable Energy (Electricity) Amendment (Excessive Noise from Wind Farms) Bill 2012 - Second Reading - Read a second time
Second reading defeated
- Aye
- 32
- No
- 36
- Not recorded voting
- 8
“Not recorded voting” is everyone eligible who isn't recorded as Aye or No, for example absent, paired, or presiding.
What was decided
The majority voted against a motion to read the bill for a second time.
This means that the majority of senators reject the main idea of the act, which was to provide the Clean Energy Regulator with powers to ensure that accredited power stations that are wind farms do not create excessive noise.(Read more about the bill here, including its explanatory memorandum. )
Background to the bill
The bill was introduced by Democratic Labor Party Senator John Madigan, also on behalf of Independent Senator Nick Xenophon.
Currently, there are questions about whether the noise generated by wind farms may cause health problems.(For example, read about the divided reactions surrounding a proposed major wind farm project in South Australia here. ) However, this is widely disputed.(For example, the South Australian Environmental Protection Authority rejected the link between wind farms and health almost a month before this vote took place (see here. ) These concerns reflect similar debates around the world in communities that are affected by wind farms.(Read more about these debates here.)
References
Summary written by They Vote For You contributors. Read it with the debate
Policies this vote counts towards
- Increasing investment in renewable energySupporters vote No
Votes by party
Votes by party as a table
| Party | Aye | No |
|---|---|---|
| Australian Labor Party | 0 | 26 |
| Liberal Party | 24 | 0 |
| Australian Greens | 0 | 9 |
| National Party | 4 | 0 |
| Country Liberal Party | 1 | 0 |
| Deputy Senate President | 1 | 0 |
| Democratic Labor Party | 1 | 0 |
| Senate President | 0 | 1 |
| Pauline Hanson's One Nation Party | 1 | 0 |
How each member voted
Aye · 32
- Nigel ScullionNT · CLP
- Stephen ParryTasmania · Deputy Senate President
- John MadiganVictoria · Labor
- Eric AbetzTasmania · Liberal
- Cory BernardiSA · Liberal
- Simon BirminghamSA · Liberal
- Sue BoyceQueensland · Liberal
- George BrandisQueensland · Liberal
- David BushbyTasmania · Liberal
- Michaelia CashWA · Liberal
- Richard ColbeckTasmania · Liberal
- Sean EdwardsSA · Liberal
- Alan EgglestonWA · Liberal
- David FawcettSA · Liberal
- Concetta Fierravanti-WellsNSW · Liberal
- Mitch FifieldVictoria · Liberal
- Bill HeffernanNSW · Liberal
- Gary HumphriesACT · Liberal
- Helen KrogerVictoria · Liberal
- Ian MacdonaldQueensland · Liberal
- Brett MasonQueensland · Liberal
- Marise PayneNSW · Liberal
- Michael RonaldsonVictoria · Liberal
- Anne RustonSA · Liberal
- Scott RyanVictoria · Liberal
- Arthur SinodinosNSW · Liberal
- Dean SmithWA · Liberal
- Ron BoswellQueensland · Nationals
- Bridget McKenzieVictoria · Nationals
- Fiona NashNSW · Nationals
No · 36
- Richard Di NataleVictoria · Greens
- Sarah Hanson-YoungSA · Greens
- Scott LudlamWA · Greens
- Christine MilneTasmania · Greens
- Lee RhiannonNSW · Greens
- Rachel SiewertWA · Greens
- Larissa WatersQueensland · Greens
- Peter Whish-WilsonTasmania · Greens
- Penny WrightSA · Greens
- Catryna BilykTasmania · Labor
- Mark BishopWA · Labor
- Carol BrownTasmania · Labor
- Doug CameronNSW · Labor
- Kim CarrVictoria · Labor
- Bob CarrNSW · Labor
- Jacinta CollinsVictoria · Labor
- Trish CrossinNT · Labor
- Chris EvansWA · Labor
- Don FarrellSA · Labor
- John FaulknerNSW · Labor
- Mark FurnerQueensland · Labor
- Alex GallacherSA · Labor
- Joe LudwigQueensland · Labor
- Kate LundyACT · Labor
- Gavin MarshallVictoria · Labor
- Anne McEwenSA · Labor
- Jan McLucasQueensland · Labor
- Claire MooreQueensland · Labor
- Helen PolleyTasmania · Labor
- Lisa SinghTasmania · Labor
Spotted a mistake? Report a correction.