24 May 2023 · 10:46 AM · Division 4
Infrastructure Australia Amendment (Independent Review) Bill 2023
- Official title
- Infrastructure Australia Amendment (Independent Review) Bill 2023 - Consideration in Detail - Cost-benefit test
Ayes in the majority
This says only which side won the vote, because what Aye and No meant here depends on the exact question put in the chamber.
- Aye
- 64
- No
- 14
- Not recorded voting
- 72
“Not recorded voting” is everyone eligible who isn't recorded as Aye or No, for example absent, paired, or presiding.
What was decided
The majority voted in favour of disagreeing with amendments introduced by Wentworth MP Allegra Spender (Independent), which means they failed.
What do the amendments do?
Ms Spender explained that:
These amendments replicate an amendment moved by the Prime Minister as the shadow minister for infrastructure in 2014. My thinking and my goals are the same as the Prime Minister's thinking and goals were at that time. The goal is to ensure that the government only invests in infrastructure projects that create benefits that are greater than the costs. To achieve this these amendments require that Infrastructure Australia cannot include projects on the infrastructure priority list unless they have undertaken a cost-benefit analysis and that analysis has returned a positive benefit. To ensure these analyses are undertaken in a reliable and consistent way without the selection of favourable variables the amendments require Infrastructure Australia to publish a standard methodology which must be used by proponents. The amendments then create the requirement that the Commonwealth not provide public funding to major projects which are not on the priority list.
In line with the Prime Minister's amendment back in 2014, a major project is defined as one worth more than $100 million.
Amendment text
See OpenAustralia.org.au for the text of the amendments.
Summary written by They Vote For You contributors. Read it with the debate
Votes by party
Votes by party as a table
| Party | Aye | No |
|---|---|---|
| Australian Labor Party | 60 | 0 |
| Independent | 0 | 10 |
| Australian Greens | 0 | 4 |
| Liberal Party | 3 | 0 |
| National Party | 1 | 0 |
How each member voted
Aye · 64
- Anne AlyCowan · Labor
- Michelle Ananda-RajahVictoria · Labor
- Matt BurnellSpence · Labor
- Josh BurnsMacnamara · Labor
- Alison ByrnesCunningham · Labor
- Jim ChalmersRankin · Labor
- Andrew CharltonParramatta · Labor
- Lisa ChestersBendigo · Labor
- Jason ClareBlaxland · Labor
- Sharon ClaydonNewcastle · Labor
- Julie CollinsFranklin · Labor
- Pat ConroyShortland · Labor
- Mary DoyleAston · Labor
- Justine ElliotRichmond · Labor
- Cassandra FernandoHolt · Labor
- Steve GeorganasAdelaide · Labor
- Andrew GilesScullin · Labor
- Patrick GormanPerth · Labor
- Luke GoslingSolomon · Labor
- Julian HillBruce · Labor
- Ed HusicChifley · Labor
- Matt KeoghBurt · Labor
- Peter KhalilWills · Labor
- Catherine KingBallarat · Labor
- Madeleine KingBrand · Labor
- Tania LawrenceHasluck · Labor
- Jerome LaxaleBennelong · Labor
- Andrew LeighFenner · Labor
- Sam LimTangney · Labor
- Zaneta MascarenhasSwan · Labor
No · 14
- Adam BandtMelbourne · Greens
- Stephen BatesBrisbane · Greens
- Max Chandler-MatherGriffith · Greens
- Elizabeth Watson-BrownRyan · Greens
- Kate ChaneyCurtin · Independent
- Zoe DanielGoldstein · Independent
- Helen HainesIndi · Independent
- Dai LeFowler · Independent
- Monique RyanKooyong · Independent
- Sophie ScampsMackellar · Independent
- Allegra SpenderWentworth · Independent
- Zali SteggallWarringah · Independent
- Kylea TinkNorth Sydney · Independent
- Andrew WilkieClark · Independent
Spotted a mistake? Report a correction.