21 Mar 2024 · 11:24 AM · Division 5
Education and Employment References Committee
- Official title
- Committees — Education and Employment References Committee; Reference
Motion defeated
- Aye
- 27
- No
- 30
- Not recorded voting
- 18
“Not recorded voting” is everyone eligible who isn't recorded as Aye or No, for example absent, paired, or presiding.
What was decided
No plain-English summary has been written for this division yet. The result above is read from the question recorded in the chamber, shown below.
Text recorded with this division
Wendy Askew
At the request of Senators Henderson, O'Sullivan and Brockman, I move:
That the following matter be referred to the Education and Employment References Committee for inquiry and report by 12 September 2024:
The issue of declining academic standards in Australian schools, with specific reference to:
(a) students' proficiency in literacy and numeracy;
(b) the experience of principals, teachers and parents in meeting the challenge of raising academic standards;
(c) the extent to which the experience of other countries with high or markedly high academic standards can inform Australian schools;
(d) what support could be provided to teachers and what improvements could be made to the Australian Curriculum to raise academic standards in Australian schools; and
(e) any other related matters.
Katy Gallagher
I seek leave to make a short statement.
Sue Lines
Leave is granted for one minute.
Katy Gallagher
The government will not be supporting this motion. It's a bit late for the coalition to be proposing this. Their record for almost a decade in government was school attendance down, high school completions down and teacher shortages up, and now they want a review. We've already done the review. The O'Brien review had a team of eminent experts visit 92 schools, hold 137 stakeholder meetings and consider 266 submissions from parents, students, teachers and experts. We have a 248-page report from them and we're getting on with the proper funding of schools and tying that funding to reforms that will lift student outcomes. I'm not sure what Senator Henderson thinks she can tell us that these experts have not.
Penny Allman-Payne
I seek leave to make a one-minute statement.
Leave granted.
I want to put on the record that the Greens, too, will be voting against this motion. Since the Gonski review we have had over 30 inquiries into schools and how they operate. We know what works; we have to get on and do it. It is insulting to every teacher and educator in the country that we are continually subjected to review. No other profession in this country is as reviewed as teachers and education. The reason we are in this mess is that we have systematically underfunded public schools for over a decade. The time for reviews needs to end. We need to get on, fund our schools and support our teachers in those schools.
Sue Lines
The question is that the motion moved by Senator Askew, at the request of Senators Henderson, O'Sullivan and Brockman, be agreed to.
This is the question as put in the chamber, with the name of the member who spoke before the vote. It isn't a summary of the bill or motion.
Votes by party
Votes by party as a table
| Party | Aye | No |
|---|---|---|
| Liberal Party | 19 | 0 |
| Australian Labor Party | 1 | 17 |
| Australian Greens | 0 | 10 |
| Liberal National Party | 2 | 0 |
| Australia's Voice | 0 | 1 |
| Country Liberal Party | 1 | 0 |
| Deputy Senate President | 1 | 0 |
| Independent | 0 | 1 |
| Jacqui Lambie Network | 1 | 0 |
| National Party | 1 | 0 |
| Senate President | 0 | 1 |
| Pauline Hanson's One Nation Party | 1 | 0 |
How each member voted
Aye · 27
- Tammy TyrrellTasmania · Labor
- Jacinta Nampijinpa PriceNT · CLP
- Slade BrockmanWA · Deputy Senate President
- Jacqui LambieTasmania · Jacqui Lambie Network
- Matthew CanavanQueensland · LNP
- James McGrathQueensland · LNP
- Alex AnticSA · Liberal
- Wendy AskewTasmania · Liberal
- Andrew BraggNSW · Liberal
- Michaelia CashWA · Liberal
- Claire ChandlerTasmania · Liberal
- Richard ColbeckTasmania · Liberal
- Jonathon DuniamTasmania · Liberal
- Sarah HendersonVictoria · Liberal
- Hollie HughesNSW · Liberal
- Maria KovacicNSW · Liberal
- Andrew McLachlanSA · Liberal
- Matt O'SullivanWA · Liberal
- James PatersonVictoria · Liberal
- Gerard RennickQueensland · Liberal
- Linda ReynoldsWA · Liberal
- Anne RustonSA · Liberal
- Paul ScarrQueensland · Liberal
- Dave SharmaNSW · Liberal
- Dean SmithWA · Liberal
- Perin DaveyNSW · Nationals
- Malcolm RobertsQueensland · One Nation
No · 30
- Fatima PaymanWA · Australia's Voice
- Penny Allman-PayneQueensland · Greens
- Mehreen FaruqiNSW · Greens
- Sarah Hanson-YoungSA · Greens
- Nick McKimTasmania · Greens
- Barbara PocockSA · Greens
- Janet RiceVictoria · Greens
- David ShoebridgeNSW · Greens
- Jordon Steele-JohnWA · Greens
- Larissa WatersQueensland · Greens
- Peter Whish-WilsonTasmania · Greens
- Tim AyresNSW · Labor
- Anthony ChisholmQueensland · Labor
- Raff CicconeVictoria · Labor
- Dorinda CoxWA · Labor
- Don FarrellSA · Labor
- Katy GallagherACT · Labor
- Varun GhoshWA · Labor
- Nita GreenQueensland · Labor
- Karen GroganSA · Labor
- Jenny McAllisterNSW · Labor
- Helen PolleyTasmania · Labor
- Louise PrattWA · Labor
- Tony SheldonNSW · Labor
- Marielle SmithSA · Labor
- Anne UrquhartBraddon · Labor
- Jess WalshVictoria · Labor
- Murray WattQueensland · Labor
- David PocockACT · Independent
- Sue LinesWA · Senate President
Spotted a mistake? Report a correction.